Menu
Rotating Ice Cream Made with Cal Poly Dairy
Locally Made I Handcrafted I Small Batch
Pints
16oz of ice cream made to share (or keep all to yourself!)
Novelties + More
Custom Orders
Looking for something special? Be sure to place your order at least 1.5 months in advance.
Little Moos
An excellent option for a party, backyard bbq, or corporate event. Pre packaged 4oz cups of flavors of your choosing.
And more! Contact us at orcutticecreamkitchen@gmail.com.
Gift Certificates
The perfect gift for the ice cream lover in your life. Available in any dollar amount.
Rotating classic Flavors
TiK’s Hawaiian Toasted Coconut
Coconut ice cream sprinkled with toasted shredded coconut.
Junie’s Birthday Jubilee
Birthday cake ice cream with a jubilee of sprinkles.
Nanny’s Nutella Churro
Cinnamon ice cream swirled with Nutella.
Milla Vanilla Bean
Simply, just vanilla.
Ben’s Old Fashioned Chocolate
‘Nuff said. Good enough to eat in your sleep.
Harry’s Cookies + Coffee
Bold coffee ice cream with Oreo cookies.
Orcutt Cowz Cookies + Cream
Vanilla ice cream with Oreo cookies - a classic!
Peg’s Vanilla Peanut Butter
Just like Lolo’s but vanilla ice cream.
Queen Madam’s Mint Chip
White mint ice cream with mini chocolate chips for a little crunch.
Orcutt Trails
Our take on the classic Rocky Road - chocolate ice cream with mini marshmallows, peanuts, and chocolate chips.
Paulie D’s Lemons & Cream
Sweet lemon ice cream made extra creamy with mascarpone added to the base. If you’re a lemon fan, you’ll love this sweet, creamy ice cream.
Brian’s Biscoff
Everyone’s favorite airplane cookie is now an ice cream. Biscoff ice cream with Biscoff cookie crumbles and Biscoff butter.
Uncle Mike’s Malted Brownie Fudge
Malted ice cream chock full of brownie chunks, fudge swirl and mini chocolate chips. A classic and nostalgic flavor!
Rachel’s Peanut Butter Dream
Peanut Butter ice cream with PB cups and Reeses Pieces throughout. The dreamiest combination. !
Seasonal flavors
Emi’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Available January - March, this ice cream features our classic Milla Vanilla Bean with mini chocolate chips and chunks of edible cookie dough.
Mom’s Almond Raspberry Swirl
Available January - April, sweet almond ice cream with sliced almonds and raspberry swirl. Just like Mom’s old fashioned raspberry bars.
Chief’s Blueberry Crumb
Available April - August. Blueberry ice cream with coffee cake crumb throughout. For every pint sold, $1 is donated to the Alzheimer’s Assocation.
Sammy’s Strawberries & Cream
Available April - August. Made with U-Pick Strawberries, local to Orcutt, this special flavor is a homage to Santa Maria. A classic.
Sue’s Butter Pecan
Available September - December. Buttery sweet ice cream with bits of pecan throughout.
Austin Annie’s Pumpkin Pie
Available September - December. Our take on a nostalgic family-favorite. Pumpkin Pie ice cream with marshmallow and graham cracker swirl.
Kitty’s Peppermint Cocoa
Available September - December. Our version of a frozen peppermint hot cocoa - with holiday spirinkles and mini marshmallows.